Last updated:
Every FHA purchase contract must include one specific piece of protective language, whether the buyer's agent thought to add it or not. The FHA Amendatory Clause and Real Estate Certification — tied to the disclosures HUD requires around Form HUD-92800.5B in the appraisal process — exists for one reason: to make sure you are never contractually forced to buy a home for more than it appraised for.
What the clause actually says
In plain language, the Amendatory Clause states that if the appraised value comes in below the sales price, the buyer has the right to:
- Walk away from the contract, and
- Get their earnest money deposit back in full
...unless the buyer voluntarily chooses to proceed anyway. It also requires that the buyer be given a copy of HUD's appraised-value disclosure, and both buyer and seller acknowledge that FHA appraisals are conducted to determine value for mortgage insurance purposes, not as a guarantee of condition.
Why HUD requires it
Before this requirement existed, some buyers found themselves contractually obligated to close at the agreed price even after a low appraisal, forfeiting a deposit if they couldn't or wouldn't come up with the difference. Because FHA insures the loan, HUD has an interest in making sure buyers are not pressured into overpaying just to avoid losing earnest money. The clause is non-negotiable in an FHA transaction — it must be attached to or incorporated into the sales contract before the loan can close.
What triggers the protection
| Scenario | Amendatory Clause protection applies? |
|---|---|
| Appraisal comes in below sales price | Yes — buyer may cancel and recover deposit |
| Appraisal meets or exceeds sales price | Not triggered; sale proceeds normally |
| Buyer changes mind for unrelated reasons | No — separate contingencies would apply |
| Property fails MPR inspection, unrelated to value | No — repair issues are addressed separately, see FHA appraisal requirements |
When it's not required
The clause is a standard part of virtually every retail FHA purchase, but a few transaction types typically fall outside its use because there's no negotiated purchase contract to attach it to:
- HUD Real Estate Owned (REO) sales — HUD is the seller and uses its own sales contract terms and as-is disclosures.
- Sheriff's sales and foreclosure auctions — there is no traditional purchase contract between a private buyer and seller.
- Certain assumption transactions where no new sales contract is being written.
If you are buying a HUD Home, ask your loan officer how HUD's own contract addenda handle appraised-value protections, since the mechanics differ from a standard resale.
Worked example (illustration only)
Assume a buyer and seller agree to a $310,000 contract price with a $6,000 earnest money deposit. The FHA appraisal returns at $298,000.
- Under the Amendatory Clause, the buyer is not obligated to close at $310,000.
- The buyer's options are the same three as any low-appraisal scenario: renegotiate the price to $298,000, bring additional cash to cover the $12,000 gap, or cancel and receive the full $6,000 deposit back.
- Without the clause, a seller could argue the buyer is in breach for refusing to close — the clause removes that risk entirely.
This example is illustrative; actual outcomes depend on your specific contract terms, state contract law, and how your agent has structured any additional appraisal contingency.
Checklist: confirm the clause is in your contract
- Ask your agent to confirm the Amendatory Clause and Real Estate Certification language is attached before you sign.
- Read the earnest money section of your contract alongside the clause — they should not conflict.
- Keep a signed copy for your file in case a dispute arises after a low appraisal.
- If buying a HUD Home or at auction, ask specifically how appraised-value risk is handled since the clause may not apply.
- Review your FHA loan process timeline so you know when the appraisal typically arrives relative to your contingency deadlines.
The Amendatory Clause is one of the more overlooked FHA protections precisely because it works quietly in the background — most buyers never need to invoke it. But if your appraisal comes in low, it's the paragraph that keeps your deposit safe.